Shiny Shelf
By Jim Smith on 22 December 2005 Comments Off

‘Infinite Crisis’ #3 is another confused and confusing issue of the potboiling mini-series.

By Mark Clapham on 10 December 2005 Comments Off

If I go for too long without reading a satisfying Batman comic, my flesh begins to itch…

By Mark Clapham on 25 November 2005 Comments Off

Unsurprisingly, this is a comic that gets it almost entirely right…

By Jim Smith on 24 November 2005 Comments Off

I was, I’ll admit it, really quite moved by the final page of ‘Infinite Crisis’ #1 the appearance of Kal-L, the Golden Age Superman, the first, best, character in super hero comics and the progenitor of the whole of this medium’s primary genre.

By Lance Parkin on 16 October 2005 Comments Off

After months and months of the set up burbling away in the background, much of it rather humdrum and offputting, the first actual issue of Infinite Crisis is here.

I like it.

By Mark Clapham on 17 September 2005 Comments Off

‘The Wintermen’ is an odd fit for Wildstorm – a thriller in the ‘Gorky Park’/'Archangel’ mould…

By Mark Clapham on 02 September 2005 Comments Off

Altogether now: ‘T-E-E-N, T-I-T-A-N-S…’

Tags: ,
By Mark Clapham on 23 August 2005 Comments Off

ABC titles without Alan Moore have been problematic…

Tags: , ,
By Mark Clapham on 23 July 2005 Comments Off

Hard Times in the Big Easy…

By Mark Clapham on 17 July 2005 Comments Off

By getting Frank Miller and Jim Lee together, the first book in DC’s new ‘All Star’ line certainly lives up to its name…

By Stephen Lavington on 05 June 2005 Comments Off

This latest issue is a storming return to form that not only ranks up there with the psychogeography one-shot ‘The Game of Cat and Mouse’ but retroactively enlivens a particularly fine story arc.

By Jim Smith on 19 April 2005 Comments Off

If yellow is the colour of fear in the spectrum of emotion… what are puce, aquamarine, indigo and lavender?

By Mark Clapham on 27 March 2005 Comments Off

The Harrowing has begun. Here are our first frontline reports…

By Mark Clapham on 17 March 2005 Comments Off

Getting a lot of things wrong can add up to make a right.

By Mark Clapham on 11 February 2005 Comments Off

To make up for the recent drought, here’s a random round-up of last week’s comics, in alphabetical order, to keep you going.

By Jim Smith on 04 January 2005 Comments Off

The most ungainly retcon in history sits at the heart of this wibbling mess of an issue and the cliffhanger ending is probably the worst I’ve ever read.

By Jim Smith on 01 December 2004 Comments Off

Some kind of error has meant that this issue of ‘Batman’ has gone out with Judd Winick’s name on the cover when he didn’t write that which is inside it.

By Jim Smith on 30 November 2004 Comments Off

It’s quite hard for me to express just how bad, and just how fundamentally wrong headed, ‘Green Lantern: Rebirth’ # 1 is.

By Jim Smith on 30 November 2004 Comments Off

Mean spirited retro-grade trash, written to a shopping list….

By Jim Smith on 26 November 2004 Comments Off

My name’s Wally West, I’m The Flash, the fastest man alive…

By Mark Clapham on 29 October 2004 Comments Off

Grant Morrison has a tendency to talk big about his work, but he can afford to – as a writer he has a tendency to takes comics, both mainstream superhero titles and more personal books, into new areas…

By Eddie Robson on 11 October 2004 Comments Off

Jeph Loeb continues to demonstrate his remarkable grasp of DCU characters: I’m starting to believe that he could even make ‘Wonder Woman’ work, although naturally writing ‘Wonder Woman’ is not a fate I would wish on anybody…

By Eddie Robson on 30 September 2004 Comments Off

To my great alarm and not inconsiderable shock, I now live in a town without a comic shop…

Tags: , ,
By Eddie Robson on 20 September 2004 Comments Off

Well, that was all a bit of a waste of time, wasn’t it?

By Jim Smith on 19 September 2004 Comments Off

It’s a consistently funny, constantly surprising riot of in-jokes, familiar designs and glorious character moments if you’re a late twentysomething manchild.

By Jim Smith on 17 August 2004 Comments Off

Death in comic books isn’t often impressive or affecting. It’s rarely even noticeable and it’s so innately reversible, defeatable and manipulatable that it doesn’t have any meaning at all.

By Mark Clapham on 21 July 2004 Comments Off

Anyone expecting an Eddie Campbell ‘Batman’ comic set in historic London to have a ‘From Hell’ level of intensity and complexity is going to be a bit disappointed by ‘The Order of the Beasts’…

By Mark Clapham on 07 July 2004 Comments Off

After the cliffhanger ending to the first volume, and all the sound and thunder of the Jim Lee ‘Coup D’etat’ issue, ‘Sleeper’ returns for its second ’season’ with an issue that is just deliriously great…

By Jim Smith on 27 May 2004 Comments Off

“DA FUG!”
‘Seaguy’ is by Grant Morrison, and that means something. What it means is that it’s the work of one of the mere two writers in the whole history of comics who can even begin to be argued to be writers of the first rank full stop. It’s the work of someone about whom using [...]

By Jim Smith on 05 May 2004 Comments Off

I’m not sure what I expected a Brian Azzarello ‘Superman’ comic to be like, but I didn’t expect it to be like this.

By Mark Clapham on 22 March 2004 Comments Off

How fast it all goes wrong…

By Eddie Robson on 14 March 2004 Comments Off

This book has had a bit of good press, so let me now redress the balance: I’ve given it three issues to impress me and, well, do I look impressed?

By Mark Clapham on 22 February 2004 Comments Off

‘Gotham Knights’ has been a blighted title since its inception. With issue #50, a change of approach has arrived…

By Mark Clapham on 22 February 2004 Comments Off

In theory, the combination of indie-comics creators with big mainstream properties is a win-win deal. This isn’t necessarily how it always works…

By Eddie Robson on 20 February 2004 Comments Off

I read this latest issue of ‘Detective Comics’ under what are perhaps the ideal conditions for reviewing a mainstream comic…

By Eddie Robson on 20 February 2004 Comments Off

My initial doubts about ‘Plastic Man’ – whether it would sustain itself over the long haul – have quickly vanished over the course of issues #2 and #3…

Tags: , ,
By Mark Clapham on 20 February 2004 Comments Off

A tale of two series: one faded bestseller, and one under-selling critical hit. Can this crossover revive the fortunes of both?

By Mark Clapham on 20 February 2004 Comments Off

‘Godfall’ is an idea we’ve seen before, but creators Turner, Kelly and Caldwell add enough twists to the story to make it work in its own right…

By Eddie Robson on 20 February 2004 Comments Off

After a couple of issues mostly comprised of big long punch-ups, this issue of ‘Superman/Batman’ provides the payoff – and it’s more than I was expecting…

By Eddie Robson on 30 November 2003 Comments Off

I do hope we’re not boring you, but here comes another round of fulsome praise for the latest work of Grant Morrison…

By Eddie Robson on 08 December 2003 Comments Off

Clearly something of a coup for DC here, as it relaunches one of its best-loved characters with a writer/artist of Kyle Baker’s credentials…

Tags: , ,
By Eddie Robson on 28 November 2003 Comments Off

I have to say, I’m very sad to see the end of Cameron Stewart’s run on ‘Catwoman’…

By Eddie Robson on 21 November 2003 Comments Off

‘Human Target’ has become one of the easiest monthly books to pick up without knowing anything about it beforehand – it is dense, involving and brilliant…

By Mark Clapham on 11 November 2003 Comments Off

After Jeph Loeb and Jim Lee’s award winning ‘Hush’, DC have decided to maintain momentum on the main Batbook by bringing in the entire team behind the Eisner-winning Vertigo title ‘100 Bullets’…

By Mark Clapham on 10 November 2003 Comments Off

Michael Chabon’s comic book debut is here…

By Eddie Robson on 10 November 2003 Comments Off

This could be the shape of things to come: the first issue of ‘Tom Strong’ to be written by someone other than Alan Moore…

By Mark Clapham on 14 October 2003 Comments Off

Old ‘Superboy’ comics are rubbish. The ‘Superboy’ TV series is rubbish. Prequels are usually rubbish. So why is ‘Smallville’ actually good?

By Jim Smith on 17 September 2003 Comments Off

It is rare that a master of their craft gets a chance to deliver an entirely appropriate farewell to their art.

By Mark Clapham on 10 September 2003 Comments Off

Over a third of the way into his story, writer Brian Azzarello and artist Eduardo Risso check in on six of their characters in these short stories…

By Jim Smith on 09 September 2003 Comments Off

Reaching as it does the dizzying heights of ‘almost readable’ and ‘bearably mediocre’ this is by far and away the best issue of Ben Raab’s disgracefully merit free run on ‘Green Lantern’.