Shiny Shelf
By Jim Smith on 11 January 2005 Comments Off

This might come as a shock to some of you, but I’ve never read a Peter David ‘Hulk’ comic before. That shouldn’t be taken as an implicit criticism of him or his previous run, by the way, it’s just a fact.

By Mark Clapham on 03 January 2005 Comments Off

As a fluffy holiday diversion, Marvel has published five ‘What If…’ one-shots, exploring alternate histories of familiar characters. The four reviewed here are strangely grim but lightweight, dealing with dark stories in a fluffy and inconsequential wa

By Mark Clapham on 03 January 2005 Comments Off

While not a masterpiece by any stretch of the imagination, the quickly-cancelled ‘Warlock’ is an OK title with some promise…

By Mark Clapham on 12 December 2004 Comments Off

‘Blade Trinity’ is a natural development of what we’ve seen before in this series, but with a quirkier sensibility…

By Mark Clapham on 28 November 2004 Comments Off

The Marvel universe is a busy, complicated place. This is clearly an attempt to create a fun, entry-level book to the wider Marvel universe for readers only really familiar with the big characters…

By Lance Parkin on 12 November 2004 Comments Off

A number of recent Marvel revamps have clearly had one eye on the movie version. You can almost see Marvel editors handing them round a Hollywood pitch meeting and saying ‘how about this?’.

By Jim Smith on 09 November 2004 Comments Off

Big ideas, big action scenes and good human writing crash together in a technology and conspiracy heavy book each issue of which really needs a couple of read throughs before it all sinks in.

By Jim Smith on 02 November 2004 Comments Off

The notes in the back of the first issue by author, and former ‘Infinity Inc’ hero, Roy Thomas make clear the writer’s great pleasure in this comic book being the most faithful adaptation of Bram Stoker’s novel in any medium.

By Mark Clapham on 04 October 2004 Comments Off

So what if Robert Kirkman created the Marvel Universe?

By Jim Smith on 15 August 2004 Comments Off

I’m not one of the those people who derides ’spandex’. I love The Flash. I love Golden Age heroes. I have no difficulty looking at pages of people wearing big collars and capes. This, however, I have a problem with.

By Mark Clapham on 15 August 2004 Comments Off

Hulk #75 finally answers the question of who is the mouth on the monitor screen manipulating events to try and get hold of the Hulk’s blood. The answer will underwhelm you…

By Eddie Robson on 30 July 2004 Comments Off

I’ve only just been able to catch up with the most recent ‘X-Statix’ storyline, and to my great delight the title is back to its old self…

By Mark Clapham on 21 July 2004 Comments Off

Sam Raimi’s first ‘Spider-Man’ movie was an almost perfect comic book movie. The sequel removes that niggling ‘almost’…

By Jim Smith on 29 June 2004 Comments Off

Robert Morales wrote ‘The Truth: Red, White and Black’ one of the very best mini-series of recent years and in it he demonstrated an ability to use Captain America in a complex, intelligent way.

By Mags L Halliday on 07 June 2004 Comments Off

I’m not sure what Marvel promise the big writers to take up the core X-Men team, but whatever it is, it’s worth it…

By Mark Clapham on 30 April 2004 Comments Off

Marvel Editor-in-Chief Joe Quesada returns to writing and drawing comics with this five-issue mini-series…

By Mark Clapham on 16 April 2004 Comments Off

Well, here’s something unique – a Mark Millar book that’s better written than it is drawn. Which is not to say that this is a brilliant script, merely that the art is worse…

By Mark Clapham on 01 March 2004 Comments Off

Marvel’s Epic experiment comes to an end with the last issue of John Jackson Miller’s ‘Crimson Dynamo’, a six-issue mini-series that has taken the old ‘Iron Man’ villain in a new direction…

By Mark Clapham on 22 February 2004 Comments Off

Another week, another Marvel comic with Spidey on the cover but not in the actual story…

By Mark Clapham on 20 February 2004 Comments Off

The trouble with Cap…

By Mark Clapham on 20 February 2004 Comments Off

In comics, good titles don’t go unused for long – even if the concepts attached to them change. Back in the 1980s, ‘Secret Wars’ saw a few dozen Marvel superheroes and supervillains abducted from Earth for spurious reasons…

By Mark Clapham on 11 January 2004 Comments Off

This is Grant Morrison’s last story arc writing ‘New X-Men’. Unsurprisingly, he isn’t going quietly…

By Mark Clapham on 30 November 2003 Comments Off

One famous issue number, six revamps of old Marvel properties… and two sexy superspies soaring to stardom.

By Mark Clapham on 23 November 2003 Comments Off

Ang Lee’s ‘Hulk’ comes to DVD with exactly the same strengths and weaknesses it had on its cinema release

By Mark Clapham on 10 November 2003 Comments Off

When ‘Alias’ launched a couple of years ago, I wasn’t terribly impressed…

By Jim Smith on 03 November 2003 Comments Off

Unluckily, he says, hitting cliche instantly, #13 shows, for the first time, ‘X-Statix’ dropping the ball.

By Eddie Robson on 23 October 2003 Comments Off

If this issue had featured Princess Diana, as it was intended to, it would have gone down as one of the greatest, most audacious comic books in Marvel’s history.

By Eddie Robson on 18 September 2003 Comments Off

This is what I hoped Epic comics would be like – esoteric, atypical Marvel product with decent talent behind it…

By Jim Smith on 17 September 2003 Comments Off

The peril of Cap in this modern world is that he invites moral absolutism. Stuck on that unfortunate line between self-pride and Nationalism as he is, he inspires both love and hatred and perhaps divides critics and readers more than any other character.

By Mark Clapham on 15 August 2003 Comments Off

Just Imagine… Shakespeare creating the Marvel Universe.

By Jim Smith on 11 August 2003 Comments Off

Supreme Power’ #1 is not quite the stellar first issue one might expect from the man who has recently been setting the comics world afire with the brilliance of his ‘Amazing Spider-Man’ run, but it’s an arresting and accomplished beginning for an ongoing

By Jim Smith on 08 August 2003 Comments Off

Garth Ennis hasn’t ever been one of comics’ more unreliable writers when it comes to getting stuff out on deadline. Not for him the long delays between issues a la Kevin Smith, or the sudden appearance of fill-ins…

By Mark Clapham on 21 July 2003 Comments Off

First things first – the beast is in good shape. ILM have created a Hulk that is convincing, and an effective amalgam of actor Eric Bana and the comic book character…

By Jim Smith on 21 July 2003 Comments Off

In what sense this Bendis scripted Spidey centric treat is ‘Ultimate X-Men’ rather than, as it seems, ‘Ultimate Marvel Team-Up Volume 2′, is so unclear as to be opaque.

By Jim Smith on 21 July 2003 Comments Off

Not since Tim Burton’s ‘Batman Returns’ has there been such a vast gap between the aims of a feature film and its portrayal via merchandise and spin-off products.

By Mark Clapham on 13 July 2003 Comments Off

Seen ‘Hulk’? Need something to fill the yawning gap between now and the next Marvel movie, ‘The Punisher’, comes out next year?

By Eddie Robson on 11 July 2003 Comments Off

Mark Millar has turned in something entirely untypical for Marvel, and in that sense it is a good opening statement for the Epic imprint. Unfortunately, in every other sense ‘Trouble’ is rubbish…

By Mark Clapham on 17 June 2003 Comments Off

Marvel go where DC fear to tread these days, or so it often seems…

By Eddie Robson on 07 June 2003 Comments Off

A bit of a disappointment, this, after Evan Dorkin’s recent ‘Agent X’ two-parter…

By Mark Clapham on 29 May 2003 Comments Off

This new comic is so relentlessly masculine that I’ve had to hide the first issue from my weaker, more vulnerable colleagues, for the good of their health…

By Mark Clapham on 24 May 2003 Comments Off

This isn’t a comic, it’s an opportunity.

By Jim Smith on 24 May 2003 Comments Off

There are people out there, mad and probably stupid, people, who believe that ‘Spider-Girl’ is an accessible, all-ages superhero title which will appeal to ‘the kids’.

By Mark Clapham on 08 May 2003 Comments Off

This book has always been the lesser of the Spidey titles…

By Mark Clapham on 30 April 2003 Comments Off

Film franchises shouldn’t function like television series, everyone knows that…

By Mark Clapham on 30 April 2003 Comments Off

Less a triumphant return to power as a decline and fall, the recent ‘Return of the King’ storyline, spinning out of the risible ‘Ultimate War’ mini-series, represents an exciting new low…

By Jim Smith on 29 April 2003 Comments Off

While sister title ‘Uncanny X-Men’ has changed writers and haemorrhaged artists with alarming frequency in recent years ‘New’ has, despite its own artist-related troubles, pursued a steady course.

By Eddie Robson on 28 April 2003 Comments Off

Well, they’ve gone and done it. This month the price of an issue of ‘X-Statix’ has gone up from $2.25 to a whopping $2.99…

By Jim Smith on 27 April 2003 Comments Off

‘X-Men 2′ has an overall dramatic tone which, like that of its predecessor, is exactly right. Neither cripplingly earnest nor floridly tongue-in-cheek, the movie imbues its fantasy elements and SF conventions with utter conviction.

By Andrew Plummer on 27 April 2003 Comments Off

As this title has been in creative flux for the last nine issues, it seems futile to try and analyse any trends…

By Eddie Robson on 26 April 2003 Comments Off

I picked this up when Mark told me that Evan Dorkin was doing a run on it. I’m a big fan of Dorkin’s work – I’d buy a ‘Gambit’ mini-series if he was on scripting duties…